What an odd morning that was.

FIA technical delegate Jo Bauer took the unusual step of issuing a communication querying the legality of the RB8 and referring the matter to the stewards, a move that was widely read as a guilty verdict for the team.

But around an hour before the race was due to start, the stewards determined - in a very carefully worded statement - that the car was legal. Just.

"The stewards received a report from the FIA Technical Delegate, along with specific ECU data from Red Bull Racing Cars 1 & 2," the stewards’ report read. "The Stewards met with the team representative and the representative of the engine supplier Renault.

"While the Stewards do not accept all the arguments of the team, they however conclude that as the regulation is written, the map presented does not breach the text of Art. 5.5.3 of the Formula One Technical Regulations and therefore decide to take no further action."

What this really means is we're back in the superfun 'spirit of the regulations'* hoo-hah that last plagued us over the Brawn double diffuser back in 2009.

What is certain is that we've not heard the last of this. The FIA will be inspecting the Red Bulls with a fine-toothed comb at every scrutineering session for the rest of the season, and we'll probably see a technical directive in the not-too-distant future that 'clarifies' Article 5.5.3.

According to Autosport there's going to be a meeting of the Technical Working Group between Hockenheim and Budapest, and if this little controversy isn't high on the agenda, then I am something incredibly unlikely.

* If you're stuck for a cheap Hallowe'en costume, I came up with a genius costume in 2009. Take one sheet, cut eyeholes in it, apply badly-drawn FIA and F1 logos, and tell everyone you're the spirit of the regulations. It's a winner.
 


Comments

goferet
22/07/2012 20:31

Actually I too was surprised Red Bull came out of this smelling like Roses for eh, isn't the FIA supposed to stand for Ferrari something???

Oh wait, I had forgotten Bernie is a Vettel fan maybe that could be it.

Well, just as long as Red Bull aren't running away with any titles, it's all water under the bridge in my book.

Reply
22/07/2012 20:41

Yeah, my main concern is that the championships stay open till the last race is possible. Much more exciting that way!

Reply
Tony Taylor
22/07/2012 21:36

I expect a clarification from the FIA will be the result of this and we won't see Red Bull try this again. A bit like the Brabham Fan Car. Oh for the days when the Le Mans stewards passed a gearbox cog wired to the dashboard of a French car as a spare wheel, and banned a lotus which had a full spare wheel but could not be used on the front or back. :-)

Reply
22/07/2012 21:49

I wish I'd been around for that era! I like it when people push the limits with a sense of humour.

Reply
22/07/2012 22:20

Glad the regulations were followed to the letter when considering the vettel overtake. What goes around comes around

Reply
22/07/2012 23:54

Amazed to see some people complaining that HAM should have had a penalty for going off track with ROS in Bahrain. That was a necessity to save his skin! VET could have hung on for another turn or two and still passed BUT, what with the latter's rubber.

Reply
elephino
25/07/2012 04:54

Hamilton didn't have to go off track in Bahrain, he decided to do so.

Now, comparing that to Hockenheim, when Hamilton did go off track, he did not overtake Rosberg then (that was once he returned to the track - noting he was level with Rosberg by the time they reached the next corner) and he gained no advantage by having gone off track (technically it could be argued he did, but that's a different argument).

25/07/2012 19:04

You should seek out the stewards' ruling on the matter, which differs greatly from your position. They have access to far more information than the casual or professional viewer, and tend not to make mistakes.

elephino
27/07/2012 04:41

Not the way I read it. I read it that I and the stewards are in agreement.

27/07/2012 15:32

No, they're seriously not. If the stewards agreed with you, Hamilton would have been given a penalty. That's kind of how the process works. Duh.




Leave a Reply